ALAC Method in Law School: A Practical Guide
Navigating legal complexities demands structured methodologies. ALAC—Answer, Legal Basis, Application, and Conclusion—is pivotal in law school exams and recitations. This method ensures clarity by starting with a direct answer, substantiating it with legal principles, applying them to scenarios, and concluding succinctly. ALAC not only enhances understanding but also sharpens legal reasoning and argumentation skills essential for academic and professional success in law.
To illustrate this method, consider the following 2022 Bar Examination Question in Civil Law:
|
Before they married in 2000, Nonoy and Daday signed a marriage settlement wherein they agreed that their property relations as husband and wife would be governed by the conjugal partnership of gains. While the marriage was subsisting, they acquired a parcel of land using conjugal funds. The Register of Deeds issued a transfer certificate of title over the said land in the name of "Nonoy, married to Daday". Nonoy sold the parcel of land to Barby without Daday's consent. Daday was not aware of the sale and did not sign the contract of sale. A year after Nonoy and Barby signed the contract of sale, Daday died. When the children of Nonoy and Daday learned about the sale to Barby, they questioned its validity since Daday had not consented to the sale. Nonoy's position is that Daday's consent was not required because the property was registered in his name. Is the sale to Barby valid? Explain briefly. (5 points) |
Answer
Begin with a clear and concise response to the question, often in the form of a straightforward "Yes" or "No." This initial answer sets the foundation for your subsequent analysis. It's important to note that examiners generally expect a definitive response; answers like "it depends" may not be suitable unless explicitly called for by the question. Avoid assuming additional facts that are not provided, as this can lead to ambiguous or inaccurate answers.
| NO, the sale to Barby is invalid. |
BONUS TIP: Avoid restating the question unless necessary for clarity, saving time and keeping your answers concise.
Legal Basis
Provide the legal foundation or principles upon which your answer is based. This involves citing relevant statutes, case law, regulations, or legal doctrines that support your position (e.g. 1987 Constitution, Family Code, Rules of Court). It's crucial to explain these sources clearly and demonstrate their applicability to the issue at hand.
|
According to the Family Code, in a conjugal partnership of gains, any property acquired during marriage, regardless of whether it is registered in one or both spouses' names, is presumed to be conjugal unless proven otherwise. Additionally, the term "married to" on a certificate of title indicates the civil status of the registered owner. For conjugal property, any conveyance or encumbrance without the written consent of the other spouse (or authorization from the court) is VOID. |
Do I need to cite the specific provision of law, including the section or article number?
NO. Examiners are well-versed in relevant laws and primarily evaluate your understanding of legal principles and their application to the issue at hand. When in doubt, it is acceptable to refer to the short title of the law or simply state "According to jurisprudence" without specifying the section number or case number. Notably, there may be multiple provisions of law or several cases reinforcing the same legal doctrine; if the examiner has a different law or case in mind, it could impact the assessment of your answer.
However, providing the particular citations can also greatly strengthen your response: it demonstrates mastery of the legal framework, clarifies your argument by pinpointing exact principles, and bolsters the persuasiveness of your analysis with authoritative references. As an additional note, citing specific provisions can impress examiners with your depth of knowledge.
Check out the resources available on Digest.PH for legal bases. Digest.PH provides:
-
Direct links to full case texts
-
A highlighting tool and bookmarking functionality
-
A legal dictionary
-
Citation generation
-
Option to download documents in PDF or Word format
These resources are tailored to support practitioners, scholars, students, and bar takers in expanding their legal knowledge. Elevate your understanding of the law today with the finest legal research tools in the Philippines!
Application/Analysis
Conduct a thorough analysis where the legal principles identified in the previous step are applied to the facts of the case or hypothetical scenario provided. This is where the examinee demonstrates his or her understanding of how the law operates in practice and how it affects the outcome of the situation.
|
In this case, the title to the land shows that the owner is married. Furthermore, the property was purchased using conjugal funds, necessitating Daday's written consent for the sale to be valid. |
Conclusion
Summarize the key points of your analysis and restate your answer in light of the legal basis and application discussed. Emphasize why your answer is legally sound and reiterate any nuances or exceptions that may affect your conclusion.
| Hence, there being no written consent from Daday, Nonoy's sale of the parcel of land to Barby is void. |
It is crucial to remember that examinations in law subjects often require contextual understanding. This entails familiarity with recent amendments, developments, and judicial rulings relevant to the applicable laws and rules. The ALAC method, though not the only approach, excels in delivering thorough and well-rounded responses. While answers may sometimes be lengthy, they ensure comprehensiveness. Nevertheless, strive for succinct answers that encapsulate the pertinent law, rules, or jurisprudence and their application to the specific problem presented. This dual emphasis on depth and conciseness not only meets academic expectations but also prepares individuals for the nuanced challenges of legal practice.
For additional tips on answering law exam questions effectively, consider exploring Answering Bar Exam Questions: Effective Techniques and Approaches.