In Re: Audit Examination

 [BLR-A-TR-09-11-05-18. November 7, 2018.](NCR-MPFO-IN-12-2017-001)IN RE: AUDIT EXAMINATIONSPECIALLY CONCERNED MEMBERS OF PNB EMPLOYEES ASSOCIATION (PEMA) and PNB R & F EMPLOYEES REPRESENTED BY ZENEN V. ATON, IDA M. DIAMANTE, ET AL., complainants-appellees, vs. PEMA AND PEMA NATIONAL EXECUTIVE BOARD, respondents-appellants.RESOLUTIONThis resolves the Partial Motion for Reconsideration filed by PEMA and PEMA National Executive Board from the Resolution dated 18 September 2018, the dispositive portion of which reads: WHEREFORE, premises considered, the Partial Memorandum of Appeal filed by Philnabank Employees Association (PEMA) and PEMA National Executive Board is PARTIALLY GRANTED. The Decision dated 13 April 2018 of DOLE National Capital Region Mediator-Arbiter Atty. Cesario P. Petate is AFFIRMED with MODIFICATION.Accordingly, respondents Joseph A. Macalinao, et al., are hereby directed to REFUND to Zenen Aton, Ida Diamante, Maria Luisa Basoc, Anna Lorraine Santua, Eric Morris Sulit, Jessie Mangubat, Mary Ann Sabay Sabay, Jenny Mae Saldaña, Zenaida Banquisio, Hilzrom Costan, Melvin Mico Castro, Mae Figueroa, Anna Mylene Tan, Fatima Bethsey Ann Ureta-Reyes, Marth Paul Albacite, Florence Ann Osorio, Erwin De Guzman, Bonnie Reyes, Cedric Sevilla, Samuel Ytac, Melizza Marie...